Perfectly Imperfect: How the Pratfall Effect Wins Hearts
- Amelia Er
- Nov 26
- 5 min read
Key Takeaways
Small mistakes can actually boost likability. Showing harmless flaws makes your brand feel more human and relatable.
Real cases prove it works. Campaigns like Domino’s “Sorry, Our Pizza Sucked” and KFC’s “FCK” apology show how honesty can win back trust.
Use it wisely. Admit minor flaws (not major disasters), show real improvement, and use honesty or humor to stay authentic.
In a world where brands constantly chase perfection, be it flawless visuals, polished slogans, or carefully curated messages, it’s often the little imperfections that win people over. This surprising truth is known as the Pratfall Effect: the idea that showing small flaws or moments of vulnerability can actually make a person, or in this case, a brand, more likable and relatable.
In marketing, this means admitting mistakes, showing authenticity, and embracing the human side of your brand. This can do more than building trust than any perfectly crafted campaign ever could. Overtime, it increases the brand's appeal, making it seem more human, relatable, and trustworthy.
Why the Pratfall Effect Works in Marketing?
When someone competent makes a small, harmless mistake, it actually makes them more likable and relatable. This happens because we tend to idealize successful people and see them as flawless. But when they slip up a little, it reminds us they are human too.
In marketing, the same idea applies to brands. Admitting small weaknesses or being openly honest can make your brand feel more genuine and human. Today’s consumers crave authenticity, and the Pratfall Effect helps brands connect on a more personal level. It shows that perfection isn’t always trustworthy, and a few imperfections can make a brand feel real, approachable, and easier to identify with.
Why Perfection Isn’t Always Persuasive?
You can argue that polished marketing can attract customers, but that isn’t always true today. In the past, highly curated and picture-perfect branding was the standard. But times have changed, and this approach is starting to feel outdated. Overly polished marketing often backfires because it trades authenticity for perfection, which can trigger audience suspicion, mistrust, and disengagement.
In today’s landscape, the more perfect something looks, the easier it is for people to ignore it. Modern consumers value honesty and authenticity far more than flawless presentation. Brands that openly admit small flaws or even poke fun at themselves tend to feel more relatable, building stronger emotional connection and loyalty.
Case Study #1 Domino’s Pizza: “We’re Sorry, Our Pizza Sucked”
In the early 2000s, Domino’s Pizza became known for having one of the worst pizzas in the fast-food industry. Customers regularly complained about the taste, and one of the most famous criticisms was that the crust “tastes like cardboard.” Instead of brushing off the negativity, Domino’s did something bold in 2009: they admitted their pizza wasn’t good.
Their “Pizza Turnaround” campaign showed real customer complaints, behind-the-scenes footage, and executives openly acknowledging the brand’s flaws. Instead of hiding the criticism, they highlighted it and used it as motivation to rebuild their product from scratch. Domino’s revamped everything from the crust to the sauce to the cheese, testing multiple variations until they created a recipe that customers actually enjoyed.
They also transformed their operations by investing heavily in technology. They introduced features like the Pizza Tracker, real-time order updates, better online ordering, and eventually even experimented with autonomous delivery.
The results were dramatic. By turning their biggest weakness into an opportunity for honesty and improvement, Domino’s rebuilt customer trust and saw sales rise. Their willingness to admit mistakes, paired with real action, became a powerful example of the Pratfall Effect in marketing.
Case Study #2
KFC: “FCK” Apology Campaign
In February 2018, KFC restaurants across the United Kingdom and Ireland faced a sudden food crisis. After switching to a new delivery partner, the supplier failed to deliver chicken on time. As a result, hundreds of locations had to put up signs telling customers they had no chicken, and in some cases, not even fries or sauces.
Rather than blaming the delivery company, KFC took a bold and cheeky approach. They released an apology ad featuring their iconic bucket, with the letters rearranged to spell “FCK.” Printed on an empty bucket, the message was humorous, self-aware, and immediately attention-grabbing.
Below the image, KFC explained the situation honestly, took responsibility, and assured customers they were working hard to fix the problem. The campaign flipped the narrative from “KFC messed up” to “KFC delivered the best apology ever.”
The ad went viral, turning a PR disaster into positive publicity. Consumers praised KFC for its humor, humility, and honesty — a perfect example of the Pratfall Effect in action.
How Brands Can Use the Pratfall Effect Wisely
As seen above, an overly polished and perfectly crafted campaign can actually push people away instead of pulling them in. Sometimes, letting a few small imperfections show can make your brand feel more real and more relatable. Here’s how to use the Pratfall Effect effectively without overdoing it:
Admit small flaws, not serious failures.
Imperfections can make your brand more likable, but it’s important to strike the right balance. Acknowledge minor shortcomings, and not serious mistakes that could harm your credibility. The goal is to appear human, not careless.
Show genuine effort to improve.
If your brand receives criticism, don’t ignore it. Show your audience that you’re listening and genuinely working to improve. Transparency and willingness to take action can strengthen trust and make customers feel valued.
Use humor or humility to humanize your brand.
You don’t always need dramatic confessions. Sometimes, simple humor or a humble tone is enough to break down walls and make your brand feel more approachable. Light, self-aware messaging can help audiences connect with you on a more personal level.
You don’t have to serve “perfect” marketing all the time. In fact, showing some behind-the-scenes chaos or admitting small slip-ups can actually make people trust your brand more. That’s the Pratfall Effect in action! When things look too perfect, they don’t feel real. A little imperfection can make your brand feel human, relatable, and easier to connect with. So instead of over-polishing everything, sometimes it’s better to show the real stuff.
References:
Comments